Defining Reality: Definitions and the Politics of Meaning by Edward Schiappa

By Edward Schiappa

Definitional disputes pop up always in a nearly countless number of contexts, from courtrooms to cocktail events. In Defining truth: Definitions and the Politics of that means, Edward Schiappa exhibits the act of defining to be a really expert and discovered habit, and accordingly person who will be studied and improved.

Through a sequence of case reports on definitional disputes approximately rape, euthanasia, abortion, and political and environmental concerns, Schiappa fosters an realizing of ways we make feel of the realm via definitions and the way we will be able to so much productively review proposed definitions. He argues that definitional disputes may be taken care of much less as philosophical questions of "is" and extra as sociopolitical questions of "ought." rather than asking "What is X?" he advocates that definitions be regarded as proposals for shared wisdom and institutional norms, as in "What should still count number as X in context Y, given our wishes and interests?"

Schiappa classifies definitions as "human-made principles we've approximately gadgets that we proportion for numerous purposes" and describes arguments approximately, from, and via definitions. based on theories that deem discourse to be persuasive, he asserts that each one discourse is definitive discourse that contributes to our building of a shared truth.

Show description

Read or Download Defining Reality: Definitions and the Politics of Meaning (Rhetorical Philosophy and Theory) PDF

Similar rhetoric books

Rhetoric (The New Critical Idiom)

Rhetoric has formed our realizing of the character of language and the aim of literature for over millennia. it's of an important significance in knowing the advance of literary heritage in addition to parts of philosophy, politics and tradition. the character and perform of rhetoric was once significant to Classical, Renaissance and Enlightenment cultures and its relevance maintains in our personal postmodern global to motivate extra debate.

Saber hablar

¿Sabe dirigirse a un público en los angeles exposición de sus argumentos y conseguir mantener su atención durante todo el tiempo? ¿Sabe al menos cómo no tartamudear y mantener l. a. compostura durante su discurso? ¿Sabe hablar en público hilvanando principles y argumentos, ser claro y directo y que su público lo entienda?

Bartlett's Familiar Quotations (18th Edition)

Greater than one hundred fifty years after its unique ebook, BARTLETT'S ordinary QUOTATIONS has been thoroughly revised and up-to-date for its eighteenth variation. BARTLETT'S showcases a sweeping survey of global heritage, from the days of old Egyptians to provide day. New authors contain Warren Buffett, the Dalai Lama, invoice Gates, David Foster Wallace, Emily publish, Steve Jobs, Jimi Hendrix, Paul Krugman, Hunter S.

Simon & Schuster Handbook for Writers

The Simon & Schuster guide for Writers, from relied on authors Lynn Troyka and Doug Hesse, provide you with the help try to be profitable. delivering the main balanced insurance of the writing procedure, grammar, examine, and subject matters, Troyka and Hesse provide you with sensible suggestion concerning the writing they you are going to do in composition classes, in different periods, and on the planet past.

Extra resources for Defining Reality: Definitions and the Politics of Meaning (Rhetorical Philosophy and Theory)

Example text

To avoid what is commonly called sensory overload, our nervous system acts as a sort of filter that attends to some stimuli (such as the markings on this page or a sudden pain) and, in effect, ignores the rest. As James put it: “We actually ignore most of the things before us” (1981, 273). Communication scholar Richard B. Gregg points out that the neurophysiological process of abstracting specific sensations from a rich environment of potential stimuli involves categorizing: “It is important to recognize that the patterned activation of sensory neuronal systems is an act of classification.

Nevertheless, Aristotle is credited for the standard definitional form involving genus and difference: An X is (a kind of) class name that has such-and-such attributes. This procedure is not solely Aristotle’s invention—“[I]t is close to Socratic definition and to the Platonic method of division” (Le Blond 1979, 67)—but Aristotle elaborates different processes of definition; thus, it is to him that the formula is usually attributed. It is worth noting that none of the Greek thinkers mentioned was interested in what would later be called “definition” purely for the sake of communicating more clearly.

As Bowerman points out, prototypical denotations are polysemic; that is, they are open to various interpretations: “Even in the relatively straightforward case of ostensive definition, when, for example, an object is shown to the child and he is told ‘dog’ or ‘that is a dog,’ much is left unexplained. What features are the critical ones that determine what new objects could or couldn’t be called ‘dog’? The fur? The presence of four legs? The color? The size? The bark? ” (1976, 114). ” Correct references to dogs will be reinforced; incorrect uses will be ignored or discouraged.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.41 of 5 – based on 19 votes